1905 Salmagundi Club, New York, NY, "26th Yearly Exhibition, Group Exhibition – Paintings by Gifford Beal, Emil Carlsen, Paul Dougherty, Robert D. Gauley, Albert L. Groll,
1905 Salmagundi Club, New York, NY, “26th Yearly Exhibition, Group Exhibition – Paintings by Gifford Beal, Emil Carlsen, Paul Dougherty, Robert D. Gauley, Albert L. Groll, Charles W. Hawthorne, and Frederick Ballard Williams”, December 1904? – January 15, 1905